Nothin’ Fancy Cakes
Simply..…delicious.
Sometimes you just want really good cake, without all of the decorations.
Our Nothin’ Fancy Cakes are simple, two-layer, 6-inch cakes featuring signature flavors and seasonal favorites. No custom decorating. No complicated decisions. Just mouth-watering cake for your small get-together...or just yourself. We won't tell.
Shop our current selection below, or request a Nothin’ Fancy Cake for a future date!
Shop Our Current Selection
Your next favorite cake is waiting…
Explore our Nothin’ Fancy Cakes, featuring signature flavors and seasonal favorites. Each cake is made with the same care and attention as our custom creations—just without all the fuss.
Quantities are limited, so find your favorite while it's available!
Sometimes you just want really good cake, without all the decorations.
Our Nothin' Fancy Cakes are simple, two-layer, 6-inch cakes made with delicious fillings and buttercreams. No custom decorating. No complicated decisions. Just mouthwatering cake.
Our Signature Flavors
Chocolate
Vanilla Almond
Specialty Flavors
Coffee Vanilla Bean Cake with Caramel Filling and Coffee Buttercream
Lemon Cake with Lemon Curd and Lemon Buttercream
Ordering & Pickup
Choose from our current inventory and select your preferred pickup location when ordering. Quantities are limited and vary by flavor.
Saturday, October 24, 2026
Ashland Pickup: 3:30–4:30 PM
Ashland Town Center Mall — north end of the parking lot near Belk.
Grayson Pickup: 5:15–6:15 PM
James Family Outfitters — parking lot.
All times Eastern.
Paducah Pickup: Available by arrangement with Short & Sweet.
Don't see your favorite flavor available? Visit our Nothin' Fancy page to request a cake for another date.
Request a Nothin’ Fancy Cake
Sold out? Planning ahead?
Don't see your favorite flavor available, or need a cake for another date? Choose your flavor and preferred pickup date below, and we'll get back to you to confirm availability.
Don't Miss the Next Sweet Thing!
Be the first to know when new Nothin’ Fancy flavors, seasonal favorites, and limited-quantity cakes become available. Join our list for sweet updates from Short & Sweet!